Saturday, 3 November 2012

Deidre and Greg come up TRUMPS.

It certainly pays to appeal ! 
We have had a dramatic reduction in our social charges bill. 
As pensioners in receipt of UK Government pensions we knew we are NOT a burden on the French state. The UK International Pensions Centre told us that the UK automatically sends £2,500 per 'State' pensioner per year to France. But you DO need to provide CPAM with your E121 / S1 plus a CPAM-stamped copy to your tax office. 

Attached is a précis of our experiences plus the original letter we sent to the tax office.   
I hope this helps,
Deirdre and Greg

Dear Val
As Deirdre has written to you concerning our problems with Social Charges, I thought that I would bring you up to date. I apologise for the wordiness, but I thought that the context of the events and out actions may be relevant.

In summary, we no longer have a problem with any of our Pensions, but still have an outstanding issue with our UK Rental income.

Early in September, we went to the Tax Office in Montauban & queried some items that the local Tax Inspector had filled in on our form 2047-K, section VIII, boxes 8TL & 8TV

In both cases, The amount filled in was our Total UK-paid pension Income, comprising :-
- State ‘old-age’ Pensions
- Private Pensions
- Employment-related pensions
- Government Civil Service (Teachers) Pension.

We were told that we needed to provide a copy of my S1 & Deirdre’s E121.

We contacted CPAM, who sent us copies of the forms, with their ‘rubber-stamp’ (tampon) on the 3rd page.

We then gave these forms (+ photocopies of our Cartes Vitale – possibly overkill). I have attached a copy the letter (page 2 below) that we wrote, to accompany these documents. It may assist others wishing to appeal.

In Mid-October we received our Social Charges bill, containing our Total Pension income under CRDS charged at 0.50 % and under CSG charges at 6.60 %

This seemed as though our S1/E121 forms had been ignored.

The Social Charges Bill also contained our UK-related Rental Income (Gross amount minus expanses) without any mention of UK-paid tax.

We then wrote a letter of appeal, covering the Pensions (S1/E121-related) & Rental Income (Subject to a separate Double Taxation Agreement (Articles 2,6 & 24).

The day after sending this second letter to the Montauban Tax Office, we received an letter from The Montauban Tax office with an adjusted amount due.

Our Pensions were no longer included in any way, other than the total refund/charge reduction was the amount of our claim relating to our Pension.

We will let you know how we get on with our appeal for the removal of our Rental Income.


We hope this clarifies matters for your readers.

Greg and Deirdre.



                                                                                                Address,
                                                                                                82140 Saint-Antonin-Noble-Val,                                                                                         Tarn et Garonne
                                                                                                FRANCE

                                                                                                Phone no

                                                septembre le 11, 2012

SIP Montauban,
SAID Secteur 2,
436 Rue Edouard Forestie,
BP 620  82080 Montauban CEDEX

No fiscal          xx-xx-xxx-xxx-xxx
Conjoint No     xx-xx-xxx-xxx-xxx
Object             Formules S1 et E121, plus les copies de nos Carte Vitales



Messieurs,
            Suite à notre rendez-vous à Montauban, lundi le 3 septembre , nous vous prions de trouver ci-joint les documents S1 et E121 que CPAM nous a envoyés.

Nous voulons nous assurer que nous payons les charges correctes et non pas plus que nécessaire.

Ces documents prouvent que nous sommes tous deux retraités depuis 2009 et que nous sommes exonéré de charges sociales – « convention Franco-britannique sur la double imposition; article 19 (pensions UK)/article 6 (Location UK) ».

Nous vous serions gré de rectifier les charges sociales en fonction de notre statut.

Dans l’attente de votre courrier, veuillez accepter, messieurs, l’expression de nos sentiments distingués,






Name(s) & Signature(s)